American Idol FInals - Week #5

So Jennifer Lopez is this week's mentor. This should be interesting!

1) Melinda Doolittle (Sway) - it was good and polished but this is the first time she hasn't blown me away. It seemed a little timid. However, her weakest performance is better than almost everyone else's best.
2) LaKisha Jones (Conga) - I am glad she did something up tempo. It was a very fun performance.
3) Chris Richardson (Smooth) - oh that was awful! Hey Chris - Justin Timberlake called and he wants you to quit trying to be him because it is not working!
4) Haley Scarnato (Turn the Beat Around) - I give her credit for getting through the "rap" part of the song and for remembering all the words. However, it was like watching someone in the Miss America pageant doing their talent.
5) Phil Stacey (Maria Maria) - all I can say is that it was better than last week. His voice kept cracking and he was off tune.
6) Jordin Sparks (The Rhythm is Gonna Get You) - another solid performance. The last note was slightly off but by far the best of the night.
7) Blake Lewis (I Need to Know) - he was copying Mark Anthony's style and phrasing through the entire thing. It was not that good.
8) Sanjaya Malakar (Besama Mucho - I know I spelled that wrong) - hell I give him credit for singing in Spanish! Maybe he needs to go on Spanish Idol because he sounds much better in Spanish than in English. What was up with the pirate look tonight?

So who will be going home tomorrow? Haley or Phil should but after last week anything is possible.